# The Cloisters Cross

> Unknown carver (attributed by Hoving to the Bury St Edmunds circle of Master Hugo) - ca. 1150-60 (Met); proposals from c. 1050 to c. 1190
> Canonical HTML: https://iconotheca.com/artworks/unknown-bury-cross-carver/cloisters-cross-met-63-12/
> Published by Servola Systems GmbH. Last verified: 2026-11-19

## Tombstone

- **Artist:** Unknown carver (attributed by Hoving to the Bury St Edmunds circle of Master Hugo)
- **Date:** ca. 1150-60 (Met); proposals from c. 1050 to c. 1190
- **Medium:** Walrus ivory
- **Dimensions:** 57.5 x 36.2 cm (22 5/8 x 14 1/4 in.); shaft 31.4 x 4.3 cm
- **Object type:** Sculpture
- **Period:** Romanesque, twelfth century
- **Current location:** The Cloisters, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Gallery 014
- **Attribution:** disputed

## Summary

A walrus-ivory cross of about 92 carved figures and 98 inscriptions, under two feet high, bought by the Met for The Cloisters in early 1963 from the Croatian dealer Ante Topic Mimara. Nothing about it before Mimara can be shown: his own account, Thomas Hoving's and a Hungarian witness's disagree. The Met catalogues it as British, ca. 1150-60, and often suggests Bury St Edmunds, but a 2026 Courtauld volume treats place, maker and patron as open.The price is reported as $600,000 in Hoving's own account as reviewed, with no primary document seen; the figure of GBP 200,000 that circulates was Mimara's asking price to the British Museum, which could not buy it because title was never established. The inscriptions, which turn the Old Testament into an argument against the Jews, are on the Met's own label.

## Provenance

Every link carries a grade. `documented` means a cited source supports it, `disputed` means the identification is argued but not established, `unknown` means we have no owner for that span and have not bridged it.

- **c. 1150-c. 1190** Unknown maker and patron `[disputed]` (origin)
  Made in the later twelfth century. Place, maker and patron are disputed: Bury St Edmunds Abbey (Hoving 1964; Parker and Little 1994), St Albans (Nilgen 1985), Hildesheim and Saxony (Munns 2013; Hennessy 2026), Denmark (Heslop 2026). The Met dates it ca. 1150-60.
- **c. 1190-c. 1948** Unknown `[unknown]` (gap)
  No owner is documented. Stories: Zirc abbey in Hungary c. 1930-33 (Kugler, recalled 1981 and 1986; unconfirmed by Zirc); a monastery of Eastern Europe, acquired 1938 (Hoving 1981) or c. 1947-48 (Hoving 1974); Volbach shown part of the cross, dirty, soon after the war (secondary report). A gap recorded as a gap.
- **c. 1948-1963** Ante Topic Mimara (Zurich bank vault) `[documented]` (private ownership)
  Mimara said in 1963 he had owned it fifteen years and refused to name the seller; the start date of his ownership is itself disputed (c. 1948 per his word; early 1950s per the Courtauld introduction). He kept it in a Zurich bank vault and offered it: to Cleveland in late 1959 ($750,000 asked), about November 1960 (about $500,000) and 1961 (GBP 200,000), declined; to the British Museum from December 1960, GBP 200,000.
- **1960-early 1963** British Museum (not completed) `[documented]` (failed sale)
  The Treasury withdrew its grant in early 1963 because title and provenance were never established. The Met purchase followed.
- **early 1963-1963** The Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Cloisters `[documented]` (purchase)
  Purchase committee approved 18 October 1962; bought early 1963 out of income from the John D. Rockefeller Jr. fund for The Cloisters. Price not in the Met's own articles; Hoving's account, as reviewed in 1981 and 1982, and Akinsha 2001 give $600,000 (secondary, disputed in detail, no primary document seen).
- **1963-present** The Metropolitan Museum of Art, The Cloisters (accession 63.12) `[documented]` (collection)
  The Cloisters Collection, 1963; Gallery 014. A Met highlight.

## Open questions

- Where was the cross between the twelfth century and about 1948? No owner, no church and no sale is documented for roughly eight centuries.
- Did it come from the Cistercian abbey of Zirc in Hungary, as Josef Kugler recalled in 1986, or from a Balkan or Baltic monastery, as Mimara said, or somewhere else? The Zirc community did not confirm it.
- When did Mimara acquire it: 1938 as Hoving's book has it, around 1947-48 as Hoving's 1974 letter and Mimara's own 1963 'fifteen years' imply, or the early 1950s as the Courtauld volume suggests?
- How much did the Met pay? $600,000 is Hoving's figure as reviewed, with no primary document seen; the Met's own articles give none. Was the 63.127 plaque or any other piece included?
- Was it carved in England at Bury St Edmunds, in Hildesheim and Saxony, in Denmark, or at a Channel Style centre such as St Albans? The 2026 editors agree only on about 1150-1190 and north-western Europe.
- Does the Oslo Corpus belong to the cross, and what stood at the base? Heslop says yes; Sauerlander and Kahsnitz say no; the base block is lost.
- What was the cross for, and who commissioned it? Nothing survives to name a patron or a church.
- Where did the tusk come from, and what are the pigments in the lettering? No isotope, DNA or pigment study of this cross has been published.
- Which twelfth-century source composed the couplet terra tremit mors victa gemit? Harcourt-Smith suggests it may have been composed for the cross.
- Was the Met right to proceed without proof of title, and has any party, including the states in whose territory Mimara worked in 1948, ever made a claim on this object? None is recorded in the sources consulted.

## Sources

- [1] Thomas P. F. Hoving, 'The Bury St. Edmunds Cross', with a prefatory note by James J. Rorimer, The Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 22, no. 10 (June 1964), pp. 317-340. Primary source for the acquisition as the Met announced it; read in full. <https://resources.metmuseum.org/resources/metpublications/pdf/The_Metropolitan_Museum_of_Art_Bulletin_v_22_no_10_June_1964.pdf>
- [2] Neil Stratford, 'The British Museum and the Cloisters Cross', in Cecily Hennessy and T. A. Heslop (eds), Revisiting the Cloisters Cross, Courtauld Books Online, 2026 (from a colloquium of 12 May 2023), chapter 3. Draws on the British Museum's own files. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/the-british-museum-and-the-cloisters-cross/>
- [3] Cecily Hennessy and T. A. Heslop, 'Introduction: Revisiting the Cloisters Cross', Courtauld Books Online, 2026. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/introduction/>
- [4] Charles T. Little, ''Through a Glass Darkly': Understanding and Misunderstanding the Cloisters Cross', Courtauld Books Online, 2026. Little is the former Met curator who co-wrote the 1994 monograph and directed the 2003-04 replica project. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/through-a-glass-darkly-understanding-and-misunderstanding-the-cloisters-cross/>
- [5] Sabrina Harcourt-Smith, 'Reflections on the Cloisters Cross in a Preaching Context', Courtauld Books Online, 2026. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/reflections-on-the-cloisters-cross-in-a-preaching-context/>
- [6] Robyn Barrow, 'The Cloisters Cross and the Walrus Tusk', Courtauld Books Online, 2026. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/the-cloisters-cross-and-the-walrus-tusk/>
- [7] Cecily Hennessy, 'The Cloisters Cross and the Sphere of Henry the Lion and Matilda of England', Courtauld Books Online, 2026. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/the-cloisters-cross-and-the-sphere-of-henry-the-lion-and-matilda-of-england/>
- [8] T. A. Heslop, 'The Cloisters Cross and the Oslo Corpus Revisited', Courtauld Books Online, 2026. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/the-cloisters-cross-and-the-oslo-corpus-revisited/>
- [9] Cecily Hennessy and T. A. Heslop, 'Conclusions', Courtauld Books Online, 2026. <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/conclusions/>
- [10] 'Dramatis personae', Revisiting the Cloisters Cross, Courtauld Books Online, 2026 (life dates and posts of the people in the story). <https://courtauld.ac.uk/research/research-resources/publications/courtauld-books-online/revisiting-the-cloisters-cross/dramatis-personae/>
- [11] Konstantin Akinsha, 'Ante Topic Mimara, The Master Swindler of Yugoslavia', ARTnews, September 2001 (reprinted at lootedart.com). <https://www.lootedart.com/MFEU4T15383>
- [12] 'The Mantle of Munchausen', review of Thomas Hoving, King of the Confessors, The New York Review of Books, 21 January 1982. Reviewer's name not captured in the page text consulted; to be added. <https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1982/01/21/the-mantle-of-munchausen/>
- [13] Robert Hughes, 'Books: Schlockmeister', Time, 16 November 1981, review of King of the Confessors. <https://time.com/archive/6698897/books-schlockmeister/>
- [14] The Metropolitan Museum of Art, collection record for The Cloisters Cross, accession 63.12, object 470305, via the Met open access API (title, culture, date, medium, dimensions, credit line, gallery, classification; no provenance or essay text in the API). The Met's web catalogue page could not be fetched (access challenge). <https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/470305>
- [15] Google Arts and Culture mirror of the Met's text for the Cloisters Cross (describes the Tree of Life design, the Moses and Brazen Serpent medallion and the terminals, and proposes Bury St Edmunds). Secondary mirror; replace with the Met's own page. <https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/TgGgu-d6o7CNRA>
- [16] Wikipedia, 'Cloisters Cross'. TERTIARY: used for the Latin tituli, the figure and inscription counts and the bibliography list only; to be replaced by the primary and Courtauld sources above. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloisters_Cross>
- [17] Wikipedia, 'Ante Topic Mimara'. TERTIARY: used for Mimara's birth and death dates and the Mimara Museum; replace with a scholarly biography. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ante_Topi%C4%87_Mimara>
- [18] Visit Bury St Edmunds, 'Abbey Treasures'. TERTIARY tourism page: used only for the 2004 replica display and for the Master Hugo summary; its GBP 200,000 'price paid' and its Zurich-vault-at-the-end-of-the-war statements are not supported by the primary sources and are not relied on. <https://visit-burystedmunds.co.uk/blog/abbey-treasures>

---

Images on this record are public domain or CC0 and are hosted by us. No image on this site is generated or simulated. If you quote this record, quote the provenance grades with it.
