# A Harvest of Death, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania

> Timothy H. O'Sullivan - July 1863 (negative); print 1865-66; published 1866
> Canonical HTML: https://iconotheca.com/artworks/timothy-h-osullivan/osullivan-a-harvest-of-death-gettysburg/
> Published by Servola Systems GmbH. Last verified: 2026-11-15

## Tombstone

- **Artist:** Timothy H. O'Sullivan
- **Date:** July 1863 (negative); print 1865-66; published 1866
- **Medium:** Albumen silver print from a wet collodion glass negative
- **Dimensions:** Image about 17.3 x 22.7 cm to 17.6 x 22.8 cm, mount 31.2 x 39.9 cm (Harvard, Library of Congress)
- **Object type:** Photograph
- **Period:** American, Civil War, nineteenth century
- **Current location:** Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York (and other collections)
- **Attribution:** accepted

## Summary

A wet collodion photograph exposed by Timothy H. O'Sullivan in the first week of July 1863 near Gettysburg, printed and published by Alexander Gardner and issued as plate 36 of his 1866 Sketch Book. Gardner's plate text called the dead Confederate; William Frassanito showed in 1975 that they are Union men of the Third Corps, photographed from two sides in plates 36 and 37.Prints survive at the Met, Harvard and the Library of Congress, among others. A print on its Sketch Book mount sold for 916 dollars including premium in 2023. The location of the negative, the day and the exact field remain open.

## Provenance

Every link carries a grade. `documented` means a cited source supports it, `disputed` means the identification is argued but not established, `unknown` means we have no owner for that span and have not bridged it.

- **July 1863** Timothy H. O'Sullivan, working with Alexander Gardner's field party `[documented]` (origin)
  The wet collodion negative was exposed in the first week of July 1863 near Gettysburg. The party reached the field on 5 July per the National Archives; catalogue dates for the negative run 4 to 7 July. Day and exact place are disputed (Frassanito: near the Rose farm and Emmitsburg Road; Coates: south of the Spangler farm).
- **1863-1866** Alexander Gardner, Washington `[documented]` (printing and publication)
  Gardner printed the picture, entered copyright in 1865 and issued it as plate 36 of the Sketch Book with Philp and Solomons in 1866. The printed mount credits O'Sullivan for the negative and Gardner for the positive.
- **1866-unknown** Unknown `[unknown]` (gap)
  The location of the original glass negative after Gardner's studio is not established in any source consulted. The Library of Congress holds a print and a copy series; no source consulted states that the original plate survives.
- **1866-2005** Unknown, then the Gilman Collection `[unknown]` (gap)
  The Met's Gilman prints (2005.100.1201 and the volume 1 copy, 2005.100.502.1) were purchased by the Museum in 2005; owners before that are not published on the pages consulted.
- **2005-present** Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York `[documented]` (acquisition)
  Accession 2005.100.1201, Gilman Collection, Museum Purchase, 2005; also plate 36 within volume 1 of the Sketch Book.
- **2008-present** Harvard Art Museums, Fogg Museum `[documented]` (acquisition)
  Object 2008.22, Richard and Ronay Menschel Fund for the Acquisition of Photographs.
- **unknown-present** Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division `[documented]` (holding)
  Print with digital ID ppmsca.12557 (LCCN 2006685384) and a copy series under reproduction number LC-B8184-7964-A. The date and route of acquisition were not available on the pages consulted.
- **unknown-11 Oct 2023** Unknown, then a private buyer at R&R Auction `[documented]` (sale)
  A Sketch Book print on a 15.75 by 12 inch mount, with its caption sheet missing, sold at R&R Auction on 11 October 2023. The prior owner is not stated.

## Auction results

Hammer and buyer's premium are stated separately. Where a source conflates them this record says so.

- **2023-10-11** R&R Auction, Fine Autograph and Artifacts (#676), lot 331, 
  - Estimate: USD 800+
  - Hammer: Not published on the page retrieved
  - With premium: Included in the total; amount not stated
  - Sold for USD 916 including buyer's premium. Albumen print on a 15.75 x 12 in mount, original caption sheet missing, light foxing and toning.
- **2017-11-17** Cowan's Auctions, American History live salesroom, lot 88, 
  - Estimate: USD 500-700
  - Hammer: Not shown
  - With premium: 28% on hammer up to USD 250,000
  - A late print, produced about the 1890s or after, not a Sketch Book print; result not shown on the page retrieved.

## Open questions

- Does the original glass negative survive, and where is it? No source consulted places it; the Library of Congress holds a copy series and a print.
- On what day and at what exact place was the negative exposed? Frassanito's Rose farm and Emmitsburg Road location, Coates's Spangler farm location with a 5 July date, and the McPherson's Woods placement in popular accounts all appear in print.
- Why did Gardner's book label the dead on plate 36 Confederate and the same dead on plate 37 Union? Frassanito corrected the identification; his reasons for the original captions are not documented in the sources consulted.
- Is the sky on the surviving prints retouched on the negative or on each print, as Cummings argues? Only an examination of the negative or a comparison of several prints under magnification would show.
- Who were the men in the picture? The Third Corps badge identifies a corps, not a person, and no individual has been named.
- How many prints survive and what did each sell for? The Sotheby's note counts sets of the book, not prints of this plate, and the market data found here is two sales and one comparison.
- What did Gardner's 1863 sales catalogue say about this view, and who did it credit? The catalogue was not available to this research.

## Sources

- [1] Wikipedia, 'A Harvest of Death'. Tertiary source, consulted for the Sketch Book plate pairing, Frassanito's 1975 argument and the reception summary. Flagged for replacement with Frassanito, Gettysburg: A Journey in Time (1975) and the Met and Library of Congress catalogue entries. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Harvest_of_Death>
- [2] Library of Congress, 'The Case of Confused Identity', Does the Camera Ever Lie?, Civil War Glass Negatives and Related Prints, Articles and Essays. Gives plates 36 and 37, reproduction numbers LC-B8184-7964-A and LC-B8171-0234, Gardner's plate text and Frassanito's analysis, pp. 222-229. <https://www.loc.gov/static/collections/civil-war-glass-negatives/articles-and-essays/does-the-camera-ever-lie/the-case-of-confused-identity.html>
- [3] Metropolitan Museum of Art, open access record, 'A Harvest of Death, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania', Timothy H. O'Sullivan, accession 2005.100.1201, Gilman Collection, Museum Purchase, 2005 (object 285644). <https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/285644>
- [4] Metropolitan Museum of Art, open access record, 'Gardner's Photographic Sketchbook of the War, Volume 1', accession 2005.100.502.1 (1-50), Gilman Collection (object 283195). <https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/283195>
- [5] Metropolitan Museum of Art, open access record, 'Field Where General Reynolds Fell, Gettysburg', accession 2005.100.502.1 (37), Gilman Collection (object 286882). <https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/286882>
- [6] Wikimedia Commons, file description for the Library of Congress print (digital ID ppmsca.12557, LCCN 2006685384): negative by T. H. O'Sullivan, positive by A. Gardner, negative July 1863, print 1866, albumen print 17.6 x 22.8 cm, public domain. <https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:A_harvest_of_death,_Gettysburg,_Pennsylvania_-_negative_by_T.H._O%27Sullivan;_positive_by_A_Gardner._LCCN2006685384.jpg>
- [7] Encyclopedia Virginia, 'A Harvest of Death, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania' (Library of Congress image page): negative July 1863, print about 1865, albumen silver print, used in the Sketch Book (1866), two volumes, 100 mounted photographs. <https://encyclopediavirginia.org/1050hpr_cf098226fcc7d5c/>
- [8] Harvard Art Museums, 'A Harvest of Death', object 2008.22, Fogg Museum, Richard and Ronay Menschel Fund for the Acquisition of Photographs: albumen silver print, image 17.3 x 22.7 cm, mount 31.2 x 39.9 cm, printed mount text with 1865 copyright entry. <https://harvardartmuseums.org/art/320569>
- [9] Sotheby's, Photographs sale 2014 (N09130), lot 25, Gardner's Photographic Sketch Book of the War, two volumes, Philp and Solomons, 1866: essay on subscription, price and surviving sets (after Anne Peterson). <https://www.sothebys.com/en/auctions/ecatalogue/2014/photographs-n09130/lot.25.html>
- [10] R&R Auction, Fine Autograph and Artifacts (#676), lot 331, 'Gettysburg, A Harvest of Death, Original Albumen Silver Print', closed 11 October 2023: sold for USD 916 including buyer's premium. <https://rrauction.com/auctions/lot-detail/li/347943906760331/cat/0>
- [11] Cowan's Auctions via Bidsquare, American History live salesroom auction, 17-18 November 2017, lot 88, 'A Harvest of Death at Gettysburg': late print, estimate USD 500-700, result not shown on the page. <https://www.bidsquare.com/online-auctions/cowans/timothy-osullivan-albumen-photograph-a-harvest-of-death-at-gettysburg-931150>
- [12] Brunk Auctions, 23 April 2026, lot 530, Sketch Book plate 44 'Slaughter Pen, Foot of Round Top, Gettysburg' (a different plate): estimate USD 3,000-5,000, sold for USD 2,600 excluding buyer's premium, 11 bids. Cited as a market comparison only. <https://live.brunkauctions.com/online-auctions/brunk/timothy-osullivan-and-alexander-gardner-8437701>
- [13] Michael E. Haskew, 'Gettysburg in Black and White', Warfare History Network. Secondary popular source; its location and unit claims conflict with the Library of Congress account and are reported here as a conflict. <https://warfarehistorynetwork.com/article/gettysburg-in-black-and-white/>
- [14] Gettysburg Daily, 'Historian Jerry Coates: Harvest of Death Part 3': Coates's location argument (south of the Henry Spangler farm buildings) and his dating of the views to 5 July 1863. <https://www.gettysburgdaily.com/historian-jerry-coates-harvest-of-death-part-3/>
- [15] John Cummings, 'Iconic Photograph of Gettysburg Dead is a Contrivance: A Harvest of Death - Gardner's Artistry', Spotsylvania Civil War Blog, 30 June 2015. A single-author blog argument about darkroom work on the sky of the print; not peer reviewed. <https://spotsylvaniacw.blogspot.com/2015/06/iconic-photograph-of-gettysburg-dead-is.html>
- [16] Emerging Civil War, 'Uncovering Fake News at the Battle of Gettysburg, July and November, 1863' (14 August 2024): dates of the Gardner and O'Sullivan work, 6 July 1863 start, and the staged sharpshooter series. <https://emergingcivilwar.com/2024/08/14/uncovering-fake-news-at-the-battle-of-gettysburg-july-and-november-1863/>
- [17] Oliver Wendell Holmes, 'Doings of the Sunbeam', Atlantic Monthly, vol. 12, no. 69 (July 1863), part 2 as reproduced in the Photo Criticism archive of historic texts. Discusses the Antietam photographs; does not mention Gettysburg. <https://www.nearbycafe.com/photocriticism/members/archivetexts/photohistory/holmes/holmessunbeam2.html>
- [18] US National Archives, Prologue blog, 'The true story behind the Gettysburg sharpshooter' (20 June 2013, Bruce Bustard): Gardner and O'Sullivan arrived at Gettysburg on 5 July 1863. <https://prologue.blogs.archives.gov/2013/06/20/the-true-story-behind-the-gettysburg-sharpshooter>
- [19] Wikipedia, 'Timothy H. O'Sullivan'. Tertiary source for the biography; flagged for replacement with a scholarly biography. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timothy_H._O%27Sullivan>
- [20] Wikimedia Commons API search and licence metadata for the files listed in images (licence read per file from LicenseShortName; Met files CC0, Library of Congress and Google Art Project files public domain). <https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/api.php?action=query&list=search&srsearch=Harvest+of+Death+Gettysburg+O%27Sullivan&srnamespace=6&format=json>

---

Images on this record are public domain or CC0 and are hosted by us. No image on this site is generated or simulated. If you quote this record, quote the provenance grades with it.
