# Mosque Lamp

> Attributed to Philippe-Joseph Brocard (possible) - Late 1800s (earlier catalogued as about 1315)
> Canonical HTML: https://iconotheca.com/artworks/philippe-joseph-brocard/mosque-lamp-brocard-cleveland-1981-10/
> Published by Servola Systems GmbH. Last verified: 2026-11-17

## Tombstone

- **Artist:** Attributed to Philippe-Joseph Brocard (possible)
- **Date:** Late 1800s (earlier catalogued as about 1315)
- **Medium:** Glass with enameled and gilded decoration
- **Dimensions:** Overall height 39.5 cm (15 9/16 in.)
- **Object type:** Glass
- **Period:** French, late nineteenth century, in the Mamluk style
- **Current location:** Cleveland Museum of Art, Gallery 116 (Islamic), Cleveland, Ohio
- **Attribution:** disputed

## Summary

A 39.5 cm brown-glass mosque lamp in Cleveland that the museum's data called a Mamluk work of about 1315 as recently as March 2019 and now catalogues as French, late 1800s, formerly in the collection of the Paris glass-enameller Philippe-Joseph Brocard and possibly made by him. The museum bought it from Spink and Son in 1981; its ownership chain runs Brocard, Georges Demotte, a dealer or collector named Ispenian, Spink, Cleveland, with undated links and long gaps.It is one of three Cleveland pieces of enameled glass, bought across thirty-seven years, that were published as medieval and are now classed as European revival work. No laboratory analysis of this lamp has been published, so the attribution is a judgment from provenance and style, not a finding.

## Provenance

Every link carries a grade. `documented` means a cited source supports it, `disputed` means the identification is argued but not established, `unknown` means we have no owner for that span and have not bridged it.

- **late 1800s** Made in France according to Cleveland's current catalogue; possibly by Philippe-Joseph Brocard `[disputed]` (origin)
  Cleveland now dates the lamp to the late 1800s and places it in France, with the statement that it is possible Brocard made it. Until at least March 2019 Cleveland data described it as Mamluk work of about 1315 from Syria or Egypt. No analysis settles the question; the present reading is the museum's judgment.
- **late 1800s** Philippe-Joseph Brocard (1831-1896), Paris `[documented]` (ownership)
  Listed first in Cleveland's provenance, dated only late 1800s. No document is published. Ownership is consistent with Brocard having made the lamp, with his having collected a medieval one or with his having restored one.
- **1896-by 1923** Unknown `[unknown]` (gap)
  Nothing links Brocard (d. 1896) to Demotte (d. 1923). The interval, up to twenty-seven years, holds no named owner.
- **undated-1923 at the latest** Georges Demotte (1877-1923), New York `[documented]` (ownership)
  Listed second in Cleveland's provenance as of New York; undated. Demotte kept galleries in Paris and New York. The date and place of acquisition are not recorded.
- **1923-before 1981** Unknown `[unknown]` (gap)
  No owner is recorded between Demotte's death and the owner called Ispenian. Demotte's galleries passed to his son Lucien according to a tertiary source; whether the lamp was among their stock is not recorded.
- **undated-1981** Ispenian (surname only; public page gives dates as unknown to 1981) `[documented]` (ownership)
  Cleveland gives a surname only. A Paul Ispenian of Paris appears in the provenance of a different, genuine Mamluk lamp now in Qatar; no source read here ties him to this lamp.
- **before 1981-1981** Spink and Son, Ltd., London `[documented]` (sale)
  Listed as the dealer that sold the lamp to the Cleveland Museum of Art. No invoice, date within 1981 or price is published.
- **1981-present** Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, Ohio `[documented]` (acquisition)
  Purchased through the John L. Severance Fund in 1981 (accession 1981.10); on view in Gallery 116. The price is not published.

## Open questions

- What do the Cleveland acquisition entries of 1982 (Sherman E. Lee, The Year in Review for 1981, p. 78 no. 8, ill. p. 68; Journal of Glass Studies 24, p. 90 no. 12) say the lamp was when it was bought, and on whose authority?
- What do Wiet 1929 p. 156 and Mayer 1933 p. 213, which Cleveland still cites for this lamp, actually describe, and is it this lamp or a Cairo lamp it may copy?
- On what date and for what reason did Cleveland change the lamp from Syria or Egypt, c. 1315, to France, late 1800s? The change falls between 15 March 2019 and 2 June 2026 and no note of it was found.
- Do the vessel glass and enamels match the Mamluk criteria set out for the Brooklyn lamp (magnesia and potash, low-lead red and blue enamel, tin-oxide white, lead-tin yellow, lazurite blue) or the nineteenth-century ones (uniformly lead-rich enamels, lead arsenate white, uranium or chromium colorants)? No analysis of 1981.10 has been published.
- Is the central mark on the underside of the foot a single or double pontil scar, and does the lamp carry a signature or mark that the open-access photographs and the record do not show?
- What does the body inscription actually read, and which sultan and school does it name? The earlier text said Muhammad ibn Qala'un and a school founded about 1315; which Cairo or other lamp is the model if it is a copy?
- Who is the Ispenian of the chain, are he or she the Paul Ispenian of Paris listed with a genuine lamp now in Qatar, and when did the lamp leave his or her hands?
- When did Georges Demotte hold the lamp, in Paris or New York, and what was the document that tied it to Brocard?
- What did Spink and Son charge, and what did Cleveland pay from the Severance Fund in 1981?
- What does Carboni and Whitehouse, Glass of the Sultans (2001), no. 135, pp. 272-273, say about the basin 1944.235, and does it comment on lamp 1981.10?

## Sources

- [1] Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access API, object record for 1981.10 Mosque Lamp (id 150188): tombstone, description, provenance, citations, exhibitions, images, CC0 flag; update stamp 2026-06-02. <https://openaccess-api.clevelandart.org/api/artworks/150188>
- [2] Cleveland Museum of Art, print page for Mosque Lamp, 1981.10 (late 1800s, France): description, Did You Know note, provenance list with Ispenian, citations, exhibition history, Gallery 116. <https://www.clevelandart.org/print/art/1981.10>
- [3] Wikimedia Commons, file page and upload history for 'Syria or Egypt, Mamluk Dynasty - Mosque Lamp - 1981.10 - Cleveland Museum of Art.tif' (file history timestamp 2019-03-15; CC0): preserves the earlier Cleveland description, date circa 1315 and place Syria or Egypt, Mamluk Dynasty. <https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Syria_or_Egypt,_Mamluk_Dynasty_-_Mosque_Lamp_-_1981.10_-_Cleveland_Museum_of_Art.tif>
- [4] Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access API, object record for 1944.488 Bottle (id 123992): c. 1900, Europe, Kevorkian provenance, citation list, description linking it to lamp 1981.10. <https://openaccess-api.clevelandart.org/api/artworks/123992>
- [5] Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access API, object record for 1944.235 Ceremonial Spittoon or Basin (id 123703): late 1800s, Europe, Morgan and Heeramaneck provenance, citation list including Hayward 1976, Atil 1981 and Carboni and Whitehouse 2001. <https://openaccess-api.clevelandart.org/api/artworks/123703>
- [6] Hollis, Howard. 'Two Examples of Arabic Enameled Glass.' Bulletin of the Cleveland Museum of Art 32, no. 10 (December 1945), pp. 179-181 (full text read at the Internet Archive). <https://archive.org/details/sim_bulletin-of-the-cleveland-museum-of-art_1945-12_32_10>
- [7] Islamic Art: Selected Examples from the Loan Exhibition of Islamic Art at the Cleveland Museum of Art. Cleveland Museum of Art, 1944 (page 38 caption for the enameled glass bottle, lent by H. Kevorkian; full text read at the Internet Archive). <https://archive.org/details/IslamicArtCMA>
- [8] Handbook of the Cleveland Museum of Art, 1978 (list of illustrations entries 44.488 and 44.235 as Mamluke period; history of the John L. Severance Fund established 1942; full text read at the Internet Archive). <https://archive.org/details/CMAHandbook1978>
- [9] Salvant, J., Schussler, S., McKenna, C., Bruno, M., Ganio, M. and Walton, M. 'Investigation of an enameled glass mosque lamp: a 13th-14th-century Mamluk example or 19th-century European version?' Heritage Science 4, article 5 (2016). Full text read. <https://doi.org/10.1186/s40494-016-0073-6>
- [10] Victoria and Albert Museum, object record 71-1890, mosque lamp by Philippe-Joseph Brocard, 1889 (V&A collections API, system number O121900): object history, bought as 'reproduction of a Damascus lamp'. <https://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O121900>
- [11] Victoria and Albert Museum, object record 1777-1869, standing bowl designed by Philippe-Joseph Brocard, c. 1869 (system number O399): received from M. Brocard 18 March 1869; museum paid 7 pounds 4 shillings. <https://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O399>
- [12] Victoria and Albert Museum, object records 415-1878 and 416-1878, goblets designed and decorated by Philippe-Joseph Brocard, 1873-78, signed 'Brocard' in enamel (system numbers O994 and O995). <https://collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O994>
- [13] Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam, BK-C-2000-1, Moskeelamp van rookkleurig glas, designer Philippe-Joseph Brocard, c. 1880, signed underneath (loan from the Nationaal Glasmuseum); description read from the museum's text on the Wikimedia Commons file page. <https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Moskeelamp_van_rookkleurig_glas_Moskeelamp,_BK-C-2000-1.jpg>
- [14] Christie's, lot 34 (Exceptional Sale, live auction 11898), Mamluk-style enameled and gilt blue glass mosque lamp, second half of the 19th century, almost certainly from a Parisian workshop: provenance, literature (Wiet 1929 p. 162 no. 40), 1903 exhibition, lot essay. Page read; estimate and result not shown on the page. <https://www.christies.com.cn/en/lot/lot-5985100>
- [15] French Wikipedia, 'Philippe-Joseph Brocard' (tertiary source; birth and death dates, patent no. 215619 of 20 August 1891, collections). To be replaced by the French archive records and patent register it cites. <https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippe-Joseph_Brocard>
- [16] Museum-collection portal mus-col.com, author page 'Brocard Philippe-Joseph' (tertiary source; 1867 Paris debut, 1878 exhibition). No external citations given on the page; to be replaced. <https://mus-col.com/en/the-authors/43604/>
- [17] English Wikipedia, 'George Joseph Demotte' (tertiary source; galleries, Great Mongol Shahnameh, 1923 lawsuits, death). To be replaced by the Time, New York Times and Iranica references it cites. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Joseph_Demotte>
- [18] Oliver Hoare Ltd, 'A Mosque Lamp' (a different lamp, 1373-1376, Museum of Islamic Art, Qatar): provenance listing Paul Ispenian, Paris. <https://oliverhoareltd.com/?p=18897>
- [19] Northwestern University Center for Scientific Studies in the Arts, project page 'Mamluk lamp' (Brooklyn Museum lamp 21.484; XRF, Raman, SEM-EDS). No mention of Cleveland. <https://scienceforart.northwestern.edu/projects-proposals/projects/mamluk-lamp.html>
- [20] Wikimedia Commons, file page 'Mosque lamp, by Phillipe Joseph Brocard, 1883-1884, glass - Wadsworth Atheneum - Hartford, CT' (public domain; photograph by Daderot; museum label as titled by the uploader). <https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mosque_lamp,_by_Phillipe_Joseph_Brocard,_1883-1884,_glass_-_Wadsworth_Atheneum_-_Hartford,_CT_-_DSC05556.jpg>
- [21] Wikimedia Commons, file page 'Mosque Lamp MET DP155253.jpg' (Metropolitan Museum of Art 17.190.986, Gift of J. Pierpont Morgan, 1917; date 19th century; CC0), imported from the Met's Open Access data. <https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Mosque_Lamp_MET_DP155253.jpg>

---

Images on this record are public domain or CC0 and are hosted by us. No image on this site is generated or simulated. If you quote this record, quote the provenance grades with it.
