# Bronze chariot inlaid with ivory (the Monteleone chariot)

> Master bronzeworker of the Monteleone chariot and his workshop - 2nd quarter of the 6th century BCE (Metropolitan Museum); about 560-550 BCE (Emiliozzi 2011)
> Canonical HTML: https://iconotheca.com/artworks/master-of-the-monteleone-chariot/monteleone-chariot-met-03-23-1/
> Published by Servola Systems GmbH. Last verified: 2026-11-19

## Tombstone

- **Artist:** Master bronzeworker of the Monteleone chariot and his workshop
- **Date:** 2nd quarter of the 6th century BCE (Metropolitan Museum); about 560-550 BCE (Emiliozzi 2011)
- **Medium:** Bronze sheet worked in repousse and incised, with ivory inlay, over a lost wooden and leather substructure
- **Dimensions:** Total height 130.9 cm (51 9/16 in.); length of pole 209 cm (82 1/4 in.)
- **Object type:** Antiquity
- **Period:** Etruscan, Archaic
- **Current location:** The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York (Department of Greek and Roman Art)
- **Attribution:** disputed

## Summary

A parade chariot of the second quarter of the sixth century BCE, sheathed in hammered bronze and inlaid with ivory, buried in a stone-lined tomb on the Colle del Capitano above Monteleone di Spoleto in Umbria. Its three main panels tell the story of Achilles: his mother Thetis bringing him new armour, his killing of Memnon and his rise to the afterlife in a chariot drawn by winged horses. Below the side panels run friezes of the boy Achilles with the centaur Chiron and of lions attacking a bull and a stag.It came to light on 8 February 1902 when a farmer levelled ground for a new house, was sold within weeks to a junk dealer in Norcia for the price of scrap iron, passed through a Roman dealer to Paris and was bought there in 1903 for the Metropolitan Museum of Art by its director Luigi Palma di Cesnola. The Italian authorities knew of the find from the summer of 1902 and failed to stop it leaving. The chariot was assembled in New York in 1903, taken apart and reassembled correctly in 2002-2007, and has been the subject of a restitution request from the municipality of Monteleone di Spoleto, which Italy's Ministry of Culture committee voted to support diplomatically in 2025. The Metropolitan Museum has said it bought the chariot in good faith.

## Provenance

Every link carries a grade. `documented` means a cited source supports it, `disputed` means the identification is argued but not established, `unknown` means we have no owner for that span and have not bridged it.

- **c. 560-550 BCE** Unknown Etruscan-Italic workshop; first owner unknown `[disputed]` (origin)
  Dated by the Metropolitan Museum to the second quarter of the 6th century BCE and by Emiliozzi to about 560-550 BCE. The city is not documented (Orvieto and Vulci proposed) and the master's background is argued three ways. Emiliozzi proposes a first owner in a major city, a hypothesis resting on ancient repairs.
- **6th century BCE-1902** A man buried in the Chariot Tomb, Colle del Capitano, Monteleone di Spoleto `[unknown]` (burial)
  The chariot was buried with a single male in a stone-lined grave under a mound. His name and the date of the burial are unknown. Emiliozzi argues the chariot had been used and repaired before burial, possibly passing between two owners. (The identity of the occupant is unknown; the inference of earlier use is Emiliozzi's.)
- **1902-02-08-1902-03-23** Isidoro Vannozzi and his son Giuseppe, landowners `[documented]` (discovery)
  Found while levelling ground for a new farmhouse on their own land. Kept at home for several weeks. Source for the date and circumstances is Emiliozzi's use of the Italian state archive and Giuseppe Vannozzi's interview. Some press accounts say a swap for two cows; Emiliozzi gives a sale to pay for roof tiles.
- **1902-03-23-1902** Benedetto Petrangeli, junk dealer, Norcia `[documented]` (sale)
  Bought at the price of scrap iron, six soldi a kilo, total 950 lire. Currency lire; the dollar equivalent given in the source has no stated method and is not adopted. Petrangeli's Norcia photographs are in the Met's archive. The early name Biga of Norcia comes from him.
- **1902-1903-02** Roman antiques dealers, then Ortensio Vitalini `[documented]` (sale)
  Petrangeli sold through Roman dealers to Vitalini for 150,000 lire (about 158 times Petrangeli's price, derived). Vitalini is described from Ludwig Pollak's memoirs as an intermediary for King Victor Emmanuel III. Dates of the individual sales are not given.
- **1902-06-1903** Italian state authorities (Carabinieri, Prefecture of Perugia, Ministry of Public Instruction) `[documented]` (seizure of part of the finds)
  Carabinieri took small objects from Vannozzi in June 1902, now in Perugia and Florence. The chariot itself had already left his hands and was not recovered.
- **1903-02-1903-04** Vitalini, with the pieces in the vaults of the Credit Lyonnais, Paris `[disputed]` (export)
  Moved to Paris in February 1903 without a recorded licence. Negotiations with other museums failed on price and doubts of authenticity. The legality of the export is disputed between the Metropolitan Museum and Monteleone di Spoleto; no route or export document is established. J. P. Morgan is reported by the New York Press (1903) to have offered 60,000 dollars and did not buy.
- **1903-04-present** The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York `[documented]` (purchase)
  Agreed with Vitalini in April 1903 by Luigi Palma di Cesnola for the trustees and paid from the Rogers Fund (Rogers Fund, 1903; accession 03.23.1). Cesnola was quoted giving 235,000 francs plus 15,000 for vases and then a dollar total that does not match; the figure is unverified. The Museum has said it bought in good faith. First shown in New York on 26 October 1903.
- **1921-present** The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York `[unknown]` (further acquisition)
  A second lot of bronzes bought in 1921 is thought by Emiliozzi to come from the Chariot Tomb or its neighbour, but the association is unproved. It does not include the chariot.

## Open questions

- By what route and under what authority did the chariot leave Italy between Roman dealers and the Paris vaults? The Italian ambassador's letter of 28 January 1903 shows legality was queried, but no export document is cited.
- Which Italian law and which export provisions applied in 1902-1903, and was any export licence applied for? The sources consulted do not give the statute text or any application.
- Did Museum officials know the export was unlawful? The claim rests on letters presented by the Comune of Monteleone di Spoleto; their full text and authentication are not in the sources consulted, and no court or ministry has ruled.
- What did the Museum pay? Cesnola's 235,000 francs plus 15,000 francs is followed by an inconsistent dollar total; no Museum ledger figure has been consulted.
- Who commissioned the chariot, and in which city? Emiliozzi proposes a prince or king of a real city and a later owner at Monteleone, but nothing documents either.
- Was the Monteleone chariot found alone, and did the 1921 lot of bronzes come from its tomb? Emiliozzi states the question is unsettled because two graves were mixed in Vannozzi's house.
- Who is the woman beneath Achilles' winged horses: Polyxena or a figure for the ground?
- Will the Museum answer the 2025 request, and has any formal reply been given?

## Sources

- [1] The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Bronze chariot inlaid with ivory, accession 03.23.1, object 247020 (open access collection API record): title, date, dimensions, credit line, culture, subject tags. <https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/public/collection/v1/objects/247020>
- [2] Adriana Emiliozzi, The Etruscan Chariot from Monteleone di Spoleto, Metropolitan Museum Journal 46 (2011). Primary scholarly source for the find, the Italian archive documents, the 1903 and 2002-2007 reconstructions, the iconography, the workshop and the ancient repairs. <https://resources.metmuseum.org/resources/metpublications/pdf/The_Etruscan_Chariot_from_Monteleone_di_Spoleto_The_Metropolitan_Museum_Journal_v_46_2011.pdf>
- [3] Wikipedia, Monteleone chariot (tertiary; used only for the restitution chronology and flagged for replacement with Italian ministry and press primary documents). Its statement that Morgan purchased the chariot is contradicted by source 2. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monteleone_chariot>
- [4] ANSA Umbria, Biga di Monteleone, il ministero affianca il Comune umbro, 29 July 2025. <https://www.ansa.it/umbria/notizie/2025/07/29/biga-di-monteleone-il-ministero-affianca-il-comune-umbro_129b45d0-5455-4a49-a6c1-24d8c7ed297a.html>
- [5] MEP Radio, Comune di Monteleone di Spoleto statement (Mayor Marisa Angelini), 28 June 2018, on the council resolution and the Berattino letters. <https://www.mepradio.it/news_online.details.php?nc=11062&cc=3>
- [6] History News Network, reprint of The Telegraph, Italian villagers fight New York's Met for 2,600-year-old chariot (Malcolm Moore, 2007): Museum spokesman on good faith, Mayor Durastanti, the two-cows account. <https://www.historynewsnetwork.org/article/37465>
- [7] Italy Magazine, New York Met Etruscan chariot possibly a fake, 14 August 2007: Jerome M. Eisenberg's forgery claim in Minerva, and expert comment on time limits. <http://www.italymagazine.com/featured-story/new-york-met-etruscan-chariot-possibly-fake>

---

Images on this record are public domain or CC0 and are hosted by us. No image on this site is generated or simulated. If you quote this record, quote the provenance grades with it.
