# Portable Altar of Countess Gertrude

> Unknown goldsmith, probably Lower Saxony; commissioned by Countess Gertrude of Brunswick - Shortly after 1038 (Cleveland, record for the altar proper, 1931.462.a) or c. 1045 (Cleveland, record for the whole object, 1931.462); the museum's date range on the whole object is 1040-1050
> Canonical HTML: https://iconotheca.com/artworks/gertrude-of-brunswick-workshop-lower-saxony-11th-century/portable-altar-countess-gertrude-cleveland-1931-462/
> Published by Servola Systems GmbH. Last verified: 2026-11-19

## Tombstone

- **Artist:** Unknown goldsmith, probably Lower Saxony; commissioned by Countess Gertrude of Brunswick
- **Date:** Shortly after 1038 (Cleveland, record for the altar proper, 1931.462.a) or c. 1045 (Cleveland, record for the whole object, 1931.462); the museum's date range on the whole object is 1040-1050
- **Medium:** Gold, cloisonne enamel, porphyry, gems, pearls, niello, wood core
- **Dimensions:** 10.5 x 27.5 x 21 cm (4 1/8 x 10 13/16 x 8 1/4 in.), overall
- **Object type:** Goldsmith's work
- **Period:** Ottonian-Salian Germany, eleventh century
- **Current location:** The Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, Ohio (gallery 106C, Medieval Treasury, per the museum's record)
- **Attribution:** unknown

## Summary

A small gold-covered portable altar with a slab of white-speckled porphyry as its stone, made shortly after 1038 or about 1045 for Countess Gertrude of Brunswick, whose Latin verse round the stone offers it to Christ. It served as the core of the treasury of the church of St Blasius in Brunswick, and its trap door still opens on a cavity that held ten labelled bundles of relics, examined in the 1980s and given new housings in 2020.It left the House of Guelph in 1929 with the whole 82-piece Guelph Treasure, bought by three Frankfurt dealer firms for 7.5 million Reichsmarks. In 1931 the Cleveland Museum of Art took the altar and the two Gertrude crosses for 320,000 dollars, according to the Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation's account, after the Metropolitan Museum was offered the same three for 450,000 and bought nothing. It has been in Cleveland ever since as accession 1931.462.The Berlin restitution dispute concerns the 42 pieces sold to Prussia in 1935. No source read says that the Cleveland pieces are involved, and the altar was sold four years before that contract. The maker, the exact date and the reading of the saints on its short side remain open.

## Provenance

Every link carries a grade. `documented` means a cited source supports it, `disputed` means the identification is argued but not established, `unknown` means we have no owner for that span and have not bridged it.

- **c. 1038-c. 1045** Countess Gertrude of Brunswick (patron), maker unknown `[documented]` (commission)
  The verse on the altar says Gertrude offered it to Christ. Cleveland dates it shortly after 1038 (altar proper) or c. 1045 (whole object). The maker and exact place are not named in any source read and Cleveland queries Lower Saxony.
- **c. 1045-1482** Collegiate church of St Blasius, Brunswick (treasury) `[unknown]` (gift to the church)
  Cleveland's open-access provenance gives the treasury of the Cathedral of St Blaise from 1045. The Museum's blog says Gertrude donated the altar with two crosses after her husband's death. No source read records a deed of gift or a date of entry, so custody is inferred from the patron and from the later inventory.
- **1482-1671** Church of St Blasius, Brunswick `[documented]` (recorded in inventory)
  The 1482 inventory of the church lists the altar and its relics, according to the Museum's blog and the Columbia project. The inventory itself was not read; Andrea Boockmann catalogued it in 1997.
- **1671-early 1920s** House of Brunswick-Luneburg (Guelph), Hanover court chapel until 1803 `[unknown]` (passed to the ducal house)
  The Foundation's magazine says the treasure came into the House's possession in 1671, and Wikipedia says most objects left the cathedral in the seventeenth century and stayed in the Hanover court chapel until 1803. Neither names this altar, and the period from 1803 to the early 1920s is a gap for the object. Tertiary source, to be replaced with the Falke, Schmidt and Swarzenski catalogue.
- **early 1920s-1929-10-05** House of Brunswick-Luneburg, treasure held at Gmunden, Austria `[documented]` (custody and failed sale efforts)
  By the early 1920s the treasure was at Gmunden. In 1925 Austria secured a purchase option in connection with export licences and the Federal Ministry waived it in January 1930. Sale efforts to Duveen, the Metropolitan Museum, the Victoria and Albert Museum, the Reich and Hanover all failed. The account is the Foundation's own submission.
- **1929-10-05-1931** Consortium of Frankfurt dealers J. and S. Goldschmidt, Z. M. Hackenbroch and J. Rosenbaum `[documented]` (purchase of the whole 82-piece treasure for RM 7.5 million)
  Altar is item 3 in the 1930 catalogue. Shown in Frankfurt and Berlin in 1930, in New York from 30 November 1930 and in Cleveland from 10 January 1931. Offered to the Metropolitan Museum with the two crosses for USD 450,000 in December 1930; not bought.
- **1931** William M. Milliken for the Cleveland Museum of Art, from the consortium via Goldschmidt Galleries, New York `[documented]` (private-treaty sale)
  The Foundation records USD 320,000 (RM 1,347,200) for the altar and the two Gertrude crosses, with an earlier purchase returned in lieu of payment and a monstrance added free. Source for the price is original documents from an auctioned Guelph catalogue, not independently checked. Cleveland's own record names Goldschmidt Galleries as vendor. No auction: there is no hammer price or premium.
- **1931-present** The Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, Ohio `[documented]` (accession 1931.462)
  Credit line Gift of the John Huntington Art and Polytechnic Trust. On view in gallery 106C per the Museum's record. Not part of the 1935 sale to Prussia.

## Open questions

- Who made the altar and where? Cleveland says 'Germany, Lower Saxony?' with a question mark, and the workshop is known only through its patron. Peter's 2001 stylistic study and Beichler's 2024 dissertation should say how firmly it is localised, and neither was read.
- Is the date shortly after 1038 or c. 1045? Cleveland's two records differ by up to seven years, and no source read says what evidence separates them.
- When did the altar enter the St Blasius treasury, and by whose act? The 1482 inventory is the first firm record read. Cleveland's account that Gertrude gave it after Liudolf's death is stated, not documented.
- Where was the altar between the seventeenth century and the 1920s? The Hanover court chapel years are stated for the treasure as a whole, and the sources read do not follow this object through them.
- Who exactly are Sigismund and Adelheid on the short side, and what does their pairing with Constantine and Helena argue? Corbet's 1991 reading was not accessible.
- Which Saint Gertrude does the bundle labelled Gertrude name? The label could mean the patron's name saint, and no source read says.
- What does the 'Adelaide' fragment actually belong to? The 2020 account says its curvature seems too pronounced for a human bone, and the bundle could not be inspected visually through its silk.
- Was USD 320,000 net of the piece Cleveland returned to the dealers? The Foundation's account does not say, and the Goldschmidt invoice is in private hands.
- What did the consortium take in? A 1934 informant, according to the Foundation, put sales at about RM 1.5 million, but the Foundation's own figures for Cleveland alone exceed that, so one number is wrong.
- Does the Cleveland Museum hold a statement on the Welfenschatz claim? None was found, and a short public line from the Museum on why the claim does not reach its pieces would close the question.
- Has the new arbitration tribunal received the Welfenschatz case, and has it decided to include any piece outside Berlin? Nothing reported to 19 November 2026 says so.

## Sources

- [1] The Cleveland Museum of Art, 'Portable Altar of Countess Gertrude', accession 1931.462, object page (description, dating, inscription translation, credit line, gallery). <https://clevelandart.org/art/1931.462>
- [2] The Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access API, records for 1931.462 and components .a to .m (dates, measurements, inscriptions, provenance, bibliography, share_license_status CC0). Read 2026-11-19. <https://openaccess-api.clevelandart.org/api/artworks/?accession_number=1931.462>
- [3] The Cleveland Museum of Art, 'Portable Altar of Countess Gertrude', accession 1931.462.a (shortly after 1038; enamel, figures and trap-door note). <https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1931.462.a>
- [4] Amanda Mikolic, 'Worshiping in Place through Art: The Hidden Gems of the Portable Altar of Countess Gertrude', Cleveland Museum of Art, 16 July 2020 (relics, 1482 inventory, stones, lock and key, conservation). The article states Liudolf died in 1077, which conflicts with the Museum's other pages and is not followed. <https://www.clevelandart.org/articles/worshiping-place-through-art-hidden-gems-portable-altar-countess-gertrude>
- [5] Holger A. Klein, entry on the Portable Altar of Countess Gertrude, Treasures of Heaven web project, Columbia University (function, figures, 1482 inventory, 1985 and 2009 handling). <https://projects.mcah.columbia.edu/treasuresofheaven/relics/Portable-Altar-of-Countess-Gertrude.html>
- [6] The Cleveland Museum of Art, 'Ceremonial Cross of Countess Gertrude', accession 1931.55. <https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1931.55>
- [7] The Cleveland Museum of Art, 'Ceremonial Cross of Count Liudolf', accession 1931.461. <https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1931.461>
- [8] Stiftung Preussischer Kulturbesitz, 'Restitution Request Guelph Treasure (Welfenschatz): Account of the established historical facts ...', as of 30 November 2010, signed Hermann Parzinger. An interested party's submission to the Advisory Commission; the Cleveland prices come from documents it describes as from an auctioned catalogue in private hands. The public PDF's Appendix III (buyers and prices) was not in the text read. <https://www.preussischer-kulturbesitz.de/fileadmin/user_upload_SPK/documents/mediathek/schwerpunkte/provenienz_eigentum/rp/Restitution_Request_Guelph_Treasure-_Account_of_the_established_historical_facts_on_the_basis_of_the_provenance_research_carried_out_by_SPK.pdf>
- [9] SPK-Magazin, 'What is the Guelph Treasure?' (1671, 1929, the 1935 sale of 42 works, today's 44, the 38 held elsewhere including Cleveland). <https://www.spkmagazin.de/en/what-is-the-guelph-treasure.html>
- [10] SPK-Magazin, 'What has happened since the 2008 restitution request for the Guelph Treasure?' (chronology to the Arbitration Tribunal of 1 December 2025). Written by a party to the dispute. <https://www.spkmagazin.de/en/what-has-happened-since-the-2008-restitution-request-for-the-guelph-treasure>
- [11] SPK-Magazin, 'Why was the sale of the Guelph Treasure not a forced sale?' (quotes the Advisory Commission's recommendation of 20 March 2014). Written by a party to the dispute. <https://www.spkmagazin.de/en/why-was-the-sale-of-the-guelph-treasure-not-a-forced-sale>
- [12] Stiftung Preussischer Kulturbesitz, press release, 'U.S. Courts Lack Jurisdiction for Guelph Treasure Lawsuit, Appeals Court Confirms', 17 July 2023. <https://www.preussischer-kulturbesitz.de/en/news-detail/article/2023/07/17/berufungsgericht-bestaetigt-unzustaendigkeit-der-us-gerichte-fuer-welfenschatz-klage.html>
- [13] Wikipedia, 'Germany v. Philipp' (docket 19-351, argued 7 December 2020, decided 3 February 2021, Roberts C.J.). Tertiary source, to be replaced by the opinion itself. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germany_v._Philipp>
- [14] Wikipedia, 'Guelph Treasure' (Hanover court chapel to 1803, nine Cleveland pieces). Tertiary source, to be replaced by the Falke, Schmidt and Swarzenski catalogue and Brunswick scholarship. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guelph_Treasure>
- [15] Wikipedia, 'Gertrude the Elder of Brunswick' (dates, St Blasius foundation, de Winter's four pieces, grave). Tertiary source, to be replaced. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gertrude_the_Elder_of_Brunswick>
- [16] Wikipedia, 'Gisela of Swabia' (marriages, children including Liudolf and Henry III, Burgundian descent). Tertiary source, to be replaced. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gisela_of_Swabia>
- [17] TIME, 'Art: Welfenschatz', 8 December 1930, page 2 (Cleveland bought six pieces as a starter; Milliken lectured as chief customer). <https://content.time.com/time/subscriber/article/0,33009,752596-2,00.html>
- [18] Patrick Corbet, "L'autel portatif de la comtesse Gertrude de Braunschweig (vers 1040)", Cahiers de civilisation medievale 34, no. 134 (1991), pp. 97-120; bibliographic page and first footnote only, text not read. <https://www.persee.fr/doc/ccmed_0007-9731_1991_num_34_134_2488>

---

Images on this record are public domain or CC0 and are hosted by us. No image on this site is generated or simulated. If you quote this record, quote the provenance grades with it.
