# Interior of the Secundra Bagh after the Slaughter of 2,000 Rebels by the 93rd Highlanders and 4th Punjab Regiment

> Felice Beato - 1858
> Canonical HTML: https://iconotheca.com/artworks/felice-beato/beato-secundra-bagh-after-the-slaughter-cleveland-2019-170-3/
> Published by Servola Systems GmbH. Last verified: 2026-11-20

## Tombstone

- **Artist:** Felice Beato
- **Date:** 1858
- **Medium:** Albumen print
- **Dimensions:** Image: 25.4 x 30.5 cm (10 x 12 in.)
- **Object type:** Photograph
- **Period:** British, 19th century (Indian Rebellion of 1857-58)
- **Current location:** Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, Ohio
- **Attribution:** accepted

## Summary

A single albumen print of 1858 by Felice Beato, showing the courtyard of the Sikandar Bagh in Lucknow, where Indian soldiers were killed by the 93rd Highlanders and the 4th Punjab Infantry on 16 November 1857. Cleveland bought it in 2019 as 2019.170.3, one of a set of 38 Beato prints of Lucknow, from the London dealer Prahlad Bubbar.The picture is known for the skulls and bones in the foreground. Museum notes and scholars say Beato may have had them uncovered, scattered or rearranged; the two eyewitness texts usually cited for this, by Sir George Campbell and William Howard Russell, are examined here and say less than the summaries of them. The set's own history is better documented than the print's: Sir William Russell, 2nd Baronet, then Christie's in 1993 (GBP 8,050 for 38 prints) and again in 2001 (GBP 11,162).Several prints of the view are in other collections, and their captions, sizes and numbers differ. This record assigns to the Cleveland print only what a source ties to 2019.170.3.

## Provenance

Every link carries a grade. `documented` means a cited source supports it, `disputed` means the identification is argued but not established, `unknown` means we have no owner for that span and have not bridged it.

- **March 1858** Felice Beato, Lucknow `[documented]` (creation)
  Negative made at the Sikandar Bagh, Lucknow. The British Library cites Fraser (1981) for March 1858; Harrington gives Beato's arrival at Lucknow as late March 1858. Cleveland dates the print 1858. The date the Cleveland print itself was made is a separate and unrecorded fact (see next link).
- **1858** Maker of this particular print (Beato's studio, or Henry Hering if printed in 1862) `[unknown]` (printing)
  Cleveland records 1858 only. The Getty credits Hering with printing a number of its Lucknow views in 1862. No source ties 2019.170.3 to either.
- **undated** Sir William Russell, 2nd Baronet `[documented]` (first recorded owner of the set)
  Named as first owner in Cleveland's six-entry provenance and in the 2001 Christie's lot page, which adds 'by descent'. No date, document or means of acquisition is given. The identification with the 7th Hussars officer (1822-1892) is an inference from the name and his Lucknow service.
- **-1993** By descent to the estate of Lady Jewel Magnus-Allcroft `[unknown]` (descent)
  The 2001 Christie's provenance line says 'by descent' and names the 1993 consignor as 'the late Lady Jewel Magnus-Allcroft'. The intermediate owners between Russell (died 1892) and Lady Magnus-Allcroft are not given.
- **20 October 1993-1993** Christie's, London (Photographs sale 5055, lot 70) `[documented]` (auction sale)
  38 light albumen prints, each about 10 x 12 in., numbered in pencil or ink on the verso; estimate GBP 6,000 to 8,000, price realised GBP 8,050. Hammer and premium are not separated. Cleveland lists this sale without lot or price.
- **1993-2001** Buyer at the 1993 sale; possibly the Kanwardip Gujral collection `[unknown]` (gap)
  The 2001 sale was titled for the Gujral Collection and the set appears in it, which suggests but does not prove that Kanwardip Gujral bought it in 1993. No source names the buyer.
- **27 September 2001-2001** Christie's, London (19C Indian Photographs from the Kanwardip Gujral Collection, sale 6455, lot 74) `[documented]` (auction sale)
  38 albumen prints, 1858, each about 10 x 12 in. (25.4 x 30.5 cm), numbered on the verso; estimate GBP 8,000 to 12,000, price realised GBP 11,162, to an order bidder per iPhotoCentral. Hammer and premium are not separated. The identity of these 38 with Cleveland's 38 is inferred from count, size and named owners.
- **2001-2019** Private collection, United Kingdom `[documented]` (private ownership)
  Cleveland's own entry. The owner is unnamed; whether the order bidder of 2001 is the same party is not recorded.
- **2019-9 September 2019** Prahlad Bubbar Indian and Islamic Art, London `[documented]` (dealer sale)
  Cleveland's own entry. The price is not published.
- **9 September 2019-present** Cleveland Museum of Art, Cleveland, Ohio `[documented]` (acquisition)
  Severance and Greta Millikin Purchase Fund, 2019.170 (38 prints), the print here being 2019.170.3. Accession date 9 September 2019 per the API. Reproduced in Tannenbaum, Acquisitions 2019: Photography, Cleveland Art 60, no. 2 (March/April 2020), p. 25. Not on view.

## Auction results

Hammer and buyer's premium are stated separately. Where a source conflates them this record says so.

- **** , 
  - Prices below are for the 38-print set of which Cleveland's print is understood to be one (the identity is inferred, see the provenance chain), not for the single print. Every figure is a price realised as published; none of the sources separates hammer from premium, so they are not treated as hammer prices. Other prices in the market for Beato's Lucknow views are for other prints.
- **1993-10-20** Christie's, London, 
  - Estimate: GBP 6,000 - 8,000
  - Hammer: Not published
  - With premium: Included in the price realised; not itemised
  - Photographs sale 5055, lot 70, India after the Siege of Lucknow, 1857-58, 38 light albumen prints. Price realised GBP 8,050 (derived: about GBP 212 a print). Buyer unknown.
- **2001-09-27** Christie's, London, 
  - Estimate: GBP 8,000 - 12,000
  - Hammer: Not published
  - With premium: Included in the price realised; not itemised
  - Sale 6455, 19C Indian Photographs from the Kanwardip Gujral Collection, lot 74, Lucknow after the Siege, 38 albumen prints. Price realised GBP 11,162 (derived: about GBP 294 a print), to an order bidder. The lot page notes VAT at 17.5 per cent on the buyer's premium; iPhotoCentral says its figures include premium.

## Open questions

- Does the verso of 2019.170.3 carry a number or inscription, and does it match the No. 13 of Beato's catalogue (British Library, CCA graphite) or the L12 of the Bonhams 2020 set? Cleveland's record lists no inscription.
- Was Cleveland's print made in 1858 or printed later, for example by Hering in 1862? No source fetched assigns this print to a printing date.
- Which Sir William Russell, 2nd Baronet, is the first owner of the set? The 7th Hussars officer of 1822-1892 fits by name and Mutiny service, but neither Christie's nor Cleveland names him.
- How did the set pass from that owner (died 1892) to the estate of Lady Jewel Magnus-Allcroft before 20 October 1993?
- Who bought lot 70 in 1993 and who was the order bidder for lot 74 in 2001? Did the Gujral collection hold the set in between? No source names the buyers.
- What do John Fraser's 1981 article (Journal of the Society for Army Historical Research, 59, pp. 51-55) and the Getty essay by Fred Ritchin say in full about the date and the arrangement of the bones? Both were read only through catalogue summaries.
- Does the Russell statement that Brown dates to April 1858 exist as a separate report in The Times, or is it the 12 March diary entry cited with another month? The diary text read for this record contains no April statement about the Secunderbagh.
- Did Beato make this view in more than one state or exposure? No source fetched says so, and the measurement spread in other collections may reflect only trimming.

## Sources

- [1] Cleveland Museum of Art, object page for 2019.170.3, Interior of the Secundra Bagh after the Slaughter of 2,000 Rebels (credit line, dimensions, rights, location). <https://clevelandart.org/art/2019.170.3>
- [2] Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access API, record for accession 2019.170.3 (id 367990): provenance entries, accession date, licence status, inscriptions, exhibitions. <https://openaccess-api.clevelandart.org/api/artworks/?accession_number=2019.170.3>
- [3] Cleveland Museum of Art, album-level record for 2019.170, Lucknow After the Siege (38 albumen prints, six provenance entries, Beato biography). <https://openaccess-api.clevelandart.org/api/collectiononline/metadata/2019.170>
- [4] Barbara Tannenbaum, 'Acquisitions 2019: Photography', Cleveland Art 60, no. 2 (March/April 2020), pp. 24-26, as published online by the museum. <https://www.clevelandart.org/articles/acquisitions-2019>
- [5] Christie's London, Photographs, 20 October 1993 (sale 5055), lot 70, India after the Siege of Lucknow, 1857-58, 38 prints, estimate and price realised. <https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-3028636>
- [6] Christie's London, 19C Indian Photographs from the Kanwardip Gujral Collection, 27 September 2001 (sale 6455), lot 74, Lucknow after the Siege, 38 prints, provenance, estimate and price realised. <https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-2534805>
- [7] Christie's, same Gujral sale, lot 4, Hodson's Horse, showing the same Russell provenance and the 1993 sale (lot 67, part lot). <https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-2534735>
- [8] iPhotoCentral newsletter no. 34 (17 October 2001), report on the Christie's Gujral Collection sale: lot 74 and total, premium note. <https://iphotocentral.com/news/article-view.php/1/32/34/141/0/0/0>
- [9] Wikipedia, 'Sir William Russell, 2nd Baronet' (tertiary): dates 1822-1892, 7th Hussars, Alumbagh and Lucknow. Flagged for replacement with ODNB or a regimental history. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sir_William_Russell,_2nd_Baronet>
- [10] Getty Research Institute, Irresistible Decay online exhibition, Beato, Sikandrah Bagh after the Slaughter of the Rebels (84.XO.1168.7), commentary on the skeletons. <https://www.getty.edu/research/exhibitions_events/exhibitions/irresistible_decay/loss/beato_sikandrah.html>
- [11] J. Paul Getty Museum, Felice Beato exhibition page for Interior of the Secundrabagh after the Slaughter of 2,000 Rebels, Lucknow (2007.26.208.7). <https://www.getty.edu/art/exhibitions/beato/lucknow.html>
- [12] Getty Museum, Felice Beato: A Photographer on the Eastern Road, exhibition checklist (Getty prints, Hering as printer, series title Lucknow - After the Mutiny, dimensions). <https://www.getty.edu/art/exhibitions/beato/beato_checklist.pdf>
- [13] Google Arts and Culture, Getty Museum entry for Beato and Hering, Interior of Secundrabagh After the Massacre (historians believe skeletons may have been rearranged). <https://artsandculture.google.com/asset/interior-of-secundrabagh-after-the-massacre/_wEjVmmrIMP0Bw>
- [14] British Library, Photo 27(2), The inside of the Secundra Bagh where 2000 men were killed: catalogue No. 13, Fraser research note, copy negatives. <https://searcharchives.bl.uk/catalog/040-003041390>
- [15] Brown University Library, Anne S. K. Brown Military Collection, Beato Lucknow album: caption, size, Fraser, Campbell and Russell note. <https://library.brown.edu/info/?p=3029>
- [16] Wellcome Collection 569457i, photograph of the Secundra Bagh interior, with duplicate 574533i. <https://wellcomecollection.org/works/jmrtgcre>
- [17] New Orleans Museum of Art, 77.67, Interior of the Secundra Bagh, Lucknow, after the Indian Mutiny of 1857-1858. <https://noma.org/?p=50695>
- [18] National Gallery of Victoria, PH5-1979, Interior of the Secundra Bagh after the slaughter of 2000 rebels by H. M. 73rd Highlanders, Lucknow, 24th Punjab Infantry. <https://www.ngv.vic.gov.au/explore/collection/work/8675/>
- [19] Canadian Centre for Architecture, PH1982:0301:013, Sikandarbagh Palace ruins, Lucknow (inscriptions 13 and No 12 [sic]). <https://www.cca.qc.ca/en/search/details/collection/object/11889>
- [20] Victoria and Albert Museum, PH.2086-1905, Interior of the Sikandra Bagh (description refers to the Bada Imambada). <https://api.vam.ac.uk/v2/object/O80929>
- [21] Sir George Campbell, Memoirs of My Indian Career, vol. 2 (London, 1893), ch. 7, 'Oude', pp. 3-4 (full text, Internet Archive). <https://archive.org/details/memoirsofmyindia02campiala>
- [22] William Howard Russell, My Diary in India in the Year 1858-9 (London, 1860), vol. 1 (entry headed 12 March; the Secunderbagh, p. 314) and vol. 2 (18 October, Cawnpore, Beato named). Full text, Internet Archive. <https://archive.org/details/mydiaryinindiai02russgoog>
- [23] Peter Harrington (curator, Anne S. K. Brown Military Collection), 'Front Man', MHQ: The Quarterly Journal of Military History 30, no. 3 (Spring 2018), online at HistoryNet. <https://www.historynet.com/front-man/>
- [24] Ateya Khorakiwala, 'Staging the Modern Ruin: Beato's Sikander Bagh, Lucknow', Thresholds 41 (April 2013); author's web page (abstract and caption only; full text not read). <https://cargocollective.com/ateyakhorakiwala/ruin>
- [25] Wikipedia, 'Sikandar Bagh' (tertiary): the action of 16 November 1857, units, losses, burial. Flagged for replacement with Kaye and Malleson or the regimental history it cites. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sikandar_Bagh>
- [26] Wikipedia, 'Felice Beato' (tertiary): biography, Robertson, India, Hering. Flagged for replacement with Lacoste (Getty, 2010) and Harrington. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felice_Beato>
- [27] Bonhams, Fine Books, Atlases, Manuscripts and Historical Photographs, London, 19 August 2020 (sale 26014), lot 159, Beato, twenty-four photographs of Lucknow with two parts of a panorama: GBP 16,312.50 including premium. <https://www.bonhams.com/auction/26014/lot/159/india-photography-beato-felice-twenty-four-photographs-of-lucknow-together-with-2-parts-of-a-panorama-1858/>
- [28] Bonhams, 2 March 2022 (sale 27372), lot 87, Beato, five views of Delhi, Secundra and Lucknow (Secundra here is Akbar's tomb near Agra): GBP 3,570 including premium. Cited only to prevent confusion. <https://www.bonhams.com/auction/27372/lot/87/beato-felice-five-views-of-delhi-secundra-and-lucknow-c1858-1862-5/>
- [29] Sotheby's London, Photographs 2008, lot 18, Beato, Lucknow, 1858, album of 75 photographs, estimate GBP 40,000-60,000 (result not shown on the page; provenance cites Sotheby's, 4 May 2000, lot 12). <https://sothebys.com/en/auctions/ecatalogue/2008/photographs-l08430/lot.18.html>
- [30] Hoax Photo Database (tertiary), 'Interior of the Secundra Bagh': a summary repeating the Campbell and Times accounts. <https://hoaxes.org/photo_database/image/interior_of_the_secundra_bagh>

---

Images on this record are public domain or CC0 and are hosted by us. No image on this site is generated or simulated. If you quote this record, quote the provenance grades with it.
